1959 Science article — total tumor regression in 60% of mice

Biophysical Approach Toward Tumor Regression in Mice

Humphrey, C. E., and Seal, E. H. (1959). Biophysical approach toward tumor regression in mice. Science 130, 388–390 (14 August 1959).
Applied Physics Laboratory, Johns Hopkins University, Silver Spring, Maryland.

Abstract

An external electrical source of low magnitude was used in a series of experiments to alter inherent tumor potentials in mice. While no significant increase of tumor growth was noted in the acceleration group, total tumor regressions were obtained in the inhibition group. Preliminary studies with leukemia did not yield significant results.

Article

It has been shown in the human being that a growing fetus or a growing uterine tumor will cause the uterus to be electronegative with respect to the outer abdominal surface (1). In the guinea pig and mouse, the tumor is also electronegative (2). This supports the many findings that a growing region is electronegative with respect to a slower growing or nongrowing region in the same organism, whether plant or animal (3, 4).

In plants, Lund has demonstrated growth acceleration and deceleration by an external potential source (4). The studies described here were based on the hypothesis that the growth rate of malignant tumor tissue would respond similarly to an external electrical source (5).

A rapidly growing type of tumor was chosen for initial experiments, and various control measures recommended by the National Cancer Institute were followed. Swiss albino mice equated for sex, age, and body weight were given trocar implants of sarcoma-180, and fur was clipped from the tumor area. Copper or zinc electrodes were covered with sponge rubber, saturated with saline solution, and placed upon the unbroken skin over the tumor area with the cathode at the tumor site for inhibition. In studies of the acceleration of tumor growth the polarity was reversed. Low values of current were used to prevent cautery. The second electrode consisted of a rest or support, made from a saline-solution-saturated sponge to which the animal was secured, the contact being made over a large, unclipped ventral area.

In experiment 1, 30 female mice were divided randomly into three equal control, acceleration, and inhibition groups. Electrode leads for the control group were separated to prevent even contact potential from entering as a variable since it could exceed the inherent tumor potential.

Current was applied to test groups for a period of 5 minutes four times daily for 7 days. All mice were sacrificed and photographed, and the tumors were removed and weighed with an accurate laboratory balance. The results appear in Table 1.

Pure direct current was chosen for all but the first experiment. A restraining device was built to handle ten animals simultaneously. The animals were secured on individual insulated rods attached to a polystyrene plate. Each rest was covered by copper and by sponge rubber for electrolyte retention. Over each mouse was placed a plastic saddle containing a rectangular copper electrode covered with sponge rubber saturated in saline solution. Each circuit was separate, with current controlled by a series rheostat.

In the second experiment, only control and inhibition animals were used. They were sacrificed after 7 days, the tumors were removed, and weight and volume determinations were made. The results are also shown in Table 1.

In the third study an acceleration group was added. One tumor in the inhibition group reached a peak in size and then began to decrease as treatment progressed. When it was removed it had the appearance of a thrombus, while the other tumors were shiny, red, and turgescent. On the fourth day of treatment a small white line appeared on the tumor; on the fifth day the line was larger and dark in color. Within the next 48 hours, invagination of the darkened area of the tumor began. Because of this effect, another experiment was conducted, and in order to attempt complete regression the animals were not sacrificed.

Table 1. Summary of data on tumor inhibition and acceleration.
ItemExperiment 1Experiment 2Experiment 3
Location of implantAxillaScapulaThoracicolumbar
Electrode sizeRound, 1 in.½ by ¾ in.1 by 1½ in.
Current2 ma at 6 v, pulsating d-c2 ma2½ ma
Prior growth of tumor24 hr78 hr48 hr
Total time of treatment⅓ hr15½ hr33 hr
Mean weight of tumors in controls1.7 g1.5 g0.66 g
Standard deviation0.60.50.11
Mean weight of inhibited tumors1.6 g1.0 g0.41 g
Standard deviation0.50.40.18
Difference probability of inhibition (t-test)< 90 percent97 percent95 percent (vol.)
Mean weight of accelerated tumors1.9 g—0.58 g
Standard deviation0.5—0.14 wt.
Difference probability of acceleration (t-test)< 90 percent—< 90 percent
Percentage acceleration10—12
Percentage inhibition63338

Twenty females were given intrascapular implants. The mice were treated for an hour and allowed to rest an hour. Treatment averaged 4.8 hours per day. The mean weight of both control and test groups was 21 g at trocar implant. Treatment began 24 hours after trocar with a current of 3 ma at 3 v.

After 15 days of treatment the tumors were measured with calipers. The mean tumor volume of treated animals was 42 percent of that of the control animals, which was 5.33 cm³.

By the 21st day all control animals had died and a 60 percent total regression of the test tumors had occurred. (Total regression means that the tumor had decreased progressively in volume, hardened, and dropped off, leaving a new skin surface at the former tumor site.)

A confirmation study was made with 18 test and 18 control animals 6 weeks old, each weighing about 25 g. A 10-day tumor growth period was allowed.

Test animals were subjected to 3 ma at 6 volts for 3 hours a day with 1 hour rest between test periods. Control animals followed the same regimen except that no current flow was permitted.

Each electrode lead was connected to a "scrambler box" so that the technician could not distinguish between control and test animals. Electrode leads to the control animals "floated" within the "scrambler box" to avoid contact potential effects. Current flow through each test animal was regulated separately by the experimenter. Animals were housed individually in a plastic cage containing wood shavings. Current density time was set for 0.016 ma hr/mm² of electrode surface area.

As treatment began, the mean volume of both test and control tumors was 3.1 cm³. At 17 days, the mean control tumor volume had increased to 5.7 cm³ and test tumor volume had increased to 4.3 cm³. At 24 days, the mean volume of the control tumors was almost 7 times the mean volume of the test tumors. The seven surviving test animals had complete tumor regression; they have survived for more than a year since trocar and are healthy, active, and free of tumors. On these animals, fur again covered the tumor site by the 50th day. Two of the controls survived 31 days.

In this confirmatory test, not tabulated, a probability of difference of 90.5 percent was found between control and test groups. Regression of tumors in the test animals is considered to be highly significant.

No differences were observed between copper and zinc electrodes. When KCl instead of NaCl was used as the electrolyte all animals died quickly.

In preliminary studies of leukemia induced by intraperitoneal L1210 tumor tissue implant, no appreciable effects were observed, although a 15 percent increase in longevity appeared to occur in the test group.

From our results with nearly 500 mice, it appears that continuation of the studies with other types of tumors is desirable (6).

Carroll E. Humphrey
E. H. Seal
Applied Physics Laboratory, Johns Hopkins University, Silver Spring, Maryland
22 April 1959

References and Notes

  1. L. Langman and H. S. Burr, Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 57, 274 (1949); Chicago Gynecological Society preliminary announcement, Science 120, 16 (1954); E. J. Ambrose and G. C. Easty, Abstr. 7th Intern. Cancer Congr. London 1958 (1959), p. 162.
  2. H. S. Burr, Yale J. Biol. and Med. 12, 277 (1939); 25, 1 (1952).
  3. ———, Medical Physics (Year Book Publishers, Chicago, 1950), vol. 2, p. 90; ——— and F. S. Hammett, Growth 3, 211 (1939); H. S. Burr, Yale J. Biol. and Med. 14, 580 (1942).
  4. E. J. Lund, Bioelectric Fields and Growth (Univ. of Texas Press, Austin, 1947).
  5. Applied Physics Laboratory, Johns Hopkins University, "Tumor regression by means of an external electrical source: announcement of preliminary findings," C. E. Humphrey, E. H. Seal, M. C. Garbow, 18 Dec. 1958.
  6. This research was performed in part under the auspices of the Applied Physics Laboratory and in part under Public Health Service grant CY 3339. Appreciation is expressed to Dr. Andervont and others of the National Cancer Institute for their valuable help, to Drs. Darden, Armbrecht, and Rubacky of Georgetown University Medical School for their help and histological analyses, to Dr. Lester Harris of Washington Missionary College for temporary laboratory space, and Dr. S. N. Stein of the Naval Medical Research Institute for laboratory space and helpful suggestions.

Original journal pages

Scanned page 1 of Humphrey & Seal (1959), Science 130:388 - Biophysical Approach toward Tumor Regression in Mice
Page 1 — Science vol. 130, p. 388 (click to enlarge)
Scanned page 2 of Humphrey & Seal (1959), Science 130:389-390 - Table 1 and references
Pages 2–3 — Science vol. 130, pp. 389–390 (click to enlarge)

Text transcribed from the original article as published in Science (American Association for the Advancement of Science), vol. 130, pp. 388–390, 14 August 1959. Reproduced here for reference and educational purposes.